Good, rugged and best hiking boots are one of the big 4 camping trip essentials (the others being a great sleeping bag, a good tent , water and backpacking stove). If any of your essentials fail on you, that’ll cut your camping trip short and you’ll have to return to civilization ASAP. An ill-fitting pair of boots or shoes can cause blisters, strained muscles, problems with your toes, and in the long term can cause knee, hip and spine issues.
We’ve reviewed a lot of boots and picked out the 5 most popular and quality options that cover a wide spectrum of needs. After you’ve read our recommendations, you can read our guide on how to choose a good shoe/boot and the important considerations you should keep in mind.
The Best Hiking Boots & Shoes This Year
Name | Weight | Waterproof | Ankle Support | Image |
Vasque Mantra 2.0 Hiking Shoe | 2 lbs 5 oz | Yes | None | |
Columbia Men’s Newton Ridge Hiking Shoe | 2 lbs 0 oz | Yes | Low | |
Merell MOAB 2 Boot | 2 lbs 4 oz | Yes | Low | |
Danner ADAMS Mountaineering Boot | 3 lbs 5 oz | Yes | High | |
Vasque St. Elias Boot | 2 lbs 15 oz | Yes | Medium |
Vasque Men’s St. Elias FG GTX: [Best Winter Hiking Boot with Vibram Soles]
The updated St. Elias boot offers premium materials, a premium leather upper and a Gore-Tex membrane lining. The full grain leather upper is easy to break in. The ATC midsole, combined with the EVA cushioning pods guarantees comfort, while the Vasque Exclusive Vibram outsole guarantees good grip on all surfaces.
Last but not least, a molded rubber toe cap will keep your toes safe on the trail. Accidentally kicking a big rock is something that happens to every hiker, and you’ll be glad you have the toe cap. This is a rugged midweight boot suited for all conditions, and it’s great for both newcomers and expert hikers. The one downside is that they might get soggy in warmer climates.
Vasque Men’s Mantra 2.0 GTX: [Lightweight Waterproof Hiking Shoe]
The lightweight Mantra low hiking shoe is a new, trendy favorite of many hikers that hike in warmer climates. It features a Gore-Tex membrane and a speed lacing system that’ll keep your feet snug on the trail, and is very comfortable to wear due to the combination of Nubuck leather and the abrasion resistant mesh upper.
The Vibram outsole will keep safe on the steep or slippery surfaces you might encounter.
This hiking shoe is a great beginner’s choice to use in the summer, or to use year-round in the warmer climates such as Nevada. The downside is that they’re less durable compared to some boots, but they’re durable enough for most hikers.
Columbia Men’s Newton Ridge: [Most Affordable Leather Hiking Shoe]
Columbia Newton Ridge are one of the most popular beginner boots out there. They’re budget friendly, have a quality leather upper, are waterproof and seam sealed. They offer a light amount of ankle support and are best suited for moderate trails.
The padded collar is comfortable but not very stiff. These boots aren’t the best choice on very harsh trails, but are the best option for a shy newcomer or a friend trying to hike for the first time. Despite not using premium materials, these boots are durable enough and will serve a casual hiker for a long time.
Merell MOAB 2: [Best Breathable Outdoor Boots]
Merrell is a well-known name in the industry and the MOAB (Mother of all Boots) midweight waterproof boots are one of the most popular boots out there. For a lot of good reasons. First thing’s first, they’re very affordable at ~$130. They’re lightweight and rugged, with a quality Vibram outsole that provides great traction and a waterproof membrane. The upper is a mix of suede leather and mesh, providing good breathability compared to any other waterproof option.
It also features a protective rubber toe cap that’s both lightweight and keeps your toes safe from rocks and other debris. They are very comfortable to wear and in many ways just like a regular office shoe.
The one downside is that they aren’t as durable as some other options out there, due to the combined mesh and leather upper, but they’ll serve an avid hiker for at least a year, while a more laid-back hiker can expect that a pair lasts him up to 3 years. Visit Merrell shoes outlet for more options.
Danner ADAMS Boots: [Premium Mountaineering Boot]
The Danner ADAMS is a heavyweight boot meant for serious mountaineering treks. They’re inspired by classic European mountaineering boots, and are boots fit for the harshest environments. A molded toe cap will protect your toes from harm, while the double-stitched full grain leather upper provides unmatched durability. These boots can last for years.
They feature Gore-Tex waterproof lining and a Vibram outsole for better traction. Compared to military boots of similar quality and durability, these are lighter and more comfortable to wear.
Their drawback is that they are heavy compared to other hiking boots and will tire you out sooner; but there’s no alternative to wearing these while you’re mountaineering in harsh climates.
Choosing a good pair of hiking boots
There are a lot of things you need to consider when you buy a boot, and we’ll list all of them. Buying the wrong boot might cut your hiking trip short and in the worst case scenario, get you into an accident. Boots are one of the big 4 items that are essential for camping, and don’t be afraid to return a pair of boots or shoes back to the store and order another pair if they don’t fit your needs.
How to choose a comfortable hiking shoe
The first and the most important thing footwear should provide is comfort. You’ll be wearing these boots for days, far longer than most people are used to. If your shoes are a poor fit, each step will feel like hell and you’ll probably have to cut your camping trip short.
If you’re wearing poorly fitting footwear, you’ll easily get blisters. Blisters, if not properly treated, could lead to a foot infection. Wear the boots around the house and go on small walks to see if they fit. Pay attention to the toe box and if all your toes fit.
Different people have different sized and shaped feet (and the feet are often not symmetrical), and you’ll need to figure out what features you need, like how wide or narrow the boot is, how good is the arch support, the heel-to-toe drop, how stiff the boot is, and if it fits insoles.
How to properly size a hiking boot
Feet don’t stay the same size during the day, and they tend to swell when you spend a lot of time on the trail. Try to go shopping for shoes in the evening, when your feet naturally swell, and try to buy a shoe a half-size larger than your normal shoes.
Account for how thick the socks you wear are, and try the footwear out while you’re wearing those socks. A good rule of thumb is that you can insert your index finger in the back heel without too much issue (or that there’s an index finger’s width of space between your toes and the toebox), and that your toes aren’t hitting the front of the shoe.
Should you go with a lightweight, heavyweight or midweight boot
Many campers don’t take the weight of their shoes into account; this is a mistake that might cost you your health over a long trail or a lifetime of hiking.
Heavyweight shoes are meant for serious wilderness backpackers that carry a lot of gear and weight, while lightweight shoes are meant for more casual hikers going on well-maintained trails.
If you’re not somebody that needs to have a heavyweight, all-terrain, all-season boot, it is strongly advised to go as light as you can. Lighter footwear is good enough protection, and your hips and knees will thank you for it in time.
On the other end of the spectrum, where protection and durability is a must, there’s nothing that can beat a good, heavyweight boot. In between, there’s the midweight category for hikers that aren’t completely in either category.
How durable are hiking boots
Quality hiking shoes last for around 800 miles, while quality hiking boots last for around a 1000 miles. You mileage may vary, depending on the trails and how often you use and maintain the shoes/boots.
Don’t be too fixated on the durability, hiking footwear will not fail you out on the trail, but it will gradually wear out. You’ll know when to buy a new pair, and many avid hikers buy three or four pairs of trusted footwear that they use up over the years.
As a rule of thumb, tough leather lasts longer but is the most uncomfortable to wear, milder leathers and nylon last a shorter while, while mesh footwear wears out the quickest.
How important is ankle support in hiking boots
Ankle support is not that important for most campers and hikers. For very heavy loads (anything above 50 lbs), you might look into stiff, durable boots that offer great ankle support. They’re very similar to high top army boots which are suited to carrying packs of upwards to 150 lbs for 9 miles, which is in no way a healthy way to hike.
For anyone else that doesn’t have to lug a weight equivalent to a smaller child in gear, ankle support is a subjective parameter. Some people prefer a bit of ankle support on tougher hikes, while others are quite content with no ankle support. This is your call.
What’s the average price of hiking boots and shoes
Most hiking boots and shoes are within the $100-$300 range. As always, it’s better to shop for quality as these boots will keep you and your feet safe on the trail, but the $100 options work just as well. More affordable shoes and boots offer lower durability, meaning you’ll need to buy more of them over time.
The higher price is often reflected in the use of premium quality materials; they’ll last a long time and you’re going to buy less boots/shoes over a lifetime.
For the more casual weekend hikers, buying budget friendly boots or shoes is good enough for a year or two. Professionals and enthusiasts should buy better gear because it’ll pay itself off over time, like Keen shoes & footwear.
Stiffness and ground insulation of hiking boots
Hiking boots and shoes are very stiff and stable compared to most other footwear; this is due to the shank, a piece of hard plastic in the sole of the boot/shoe. Some boots and shoes are meant for mountaineering, and have a very long and hard shank. This isn’t a problem when you’re going over harsh terrain or snow, but can be fatiguing on a more casual hike.
If you’re hiking in an area that has sharp rocks, debris and other hard matter on the trail, these are your best bet. Some people have a personal preference for a softer feeling shoe or boot and might go for an option in the middle. Midway shoes are durable and comfortable enough, and shine in rugged hikes with lots of loose rock and gravel under your feet.
Lightweight shoes and boots often forego the use of a shank and feel like regular shoes. These are the best option for well-kept trails in national parks and easy trails, and are the most comfortable of the three.
Waterproof Outdoors Boots and Shoes
Most hiking boots and shoes today are waterproof; or at least have a waterproof option. Most newcomers opt to get waterproof boots because wearing soggy, wet socks for an entire day is an experience everyone would gladly avoid.
Gore-tex (abbreviated to GTX) lining is a very popular option for most boots today; most of the hiking boots and shoes are waterproof.
There are pros and cons to being waterproof. The pros are that they function admirably in cold, wet environments, and you don’t have to worry about your feet getting wet if you’re crossing a shallow stream or that accidentally stepping into a puddle will ruin your day.
The cons are that they’re not breathable, and your feet will most likely sweat and make the inside of the boot soggy. Being waterproof both keeps outside water out, and inside water in. They’re notoriously hard to dry.
Breathability, the polar opposite of a Waterproof boot
For hikers and campers that usually go out into the wilderness in the summer (which is the most popular outdoors season), breathability might beat out waterproofing.
In hot and dry states like Nevada and California, campers and hikers find that breathability always beats having a waterproof shoe, while in colder states like Indiana, waterproof boots and shoes are key to having a safe hike in the wild.
How to waterproof your hiking boots?
Factory new boots have been treated with a water-repellent finish, and most boots will be waterproof for quite some time in use. After a while, the finish will wear off and the boots will no longer be waterproof. Aftermarket waterproofing treatments, designed for a specific type of material, are a quick and easy fix. Be sure to get the right type of waterproof for your specific type of leather; you’ll have diminished results if you use rough leather waterproofing treatments for full-grain leather boots.
They’ll keep your boots waterproof for a couple of more seasons. Before you apply the solution, clean your boots up with a boot cleaner, a soft brush, and water. Wax-based waterproofing that many “lifehack” websites propagate isn’t a good idea; it’s outdated and it leaves wax residue that makes your shoes harder to maintain and fix. It doesn’t last long; the layer of wax is naturally rubbed off by the small flexing of the shoe’s material during day-to-day walking.
Ultimately, there’s no getting around the fact that boots aren’t something you buy for life. They’ll wear out, they’ll get damaged on the trail, and eventually, you’ll need to replace them.
Traction on slippery surfaces
Depending on where you’re going, traction can make or break your hike. Slippery, steep or rocky trails, or crossing a stream require a “stickier” boot. The difference between a regular trail shoe and a hiking boot usually lies in the outsole construction.
Vibram is an Italian-made (or licensed) rubber that is used in outsoles for traction; almost all hiking boots and shoes use it. Not all Vibram is created equal, small changes to the formula can control stiffness, stickiness and changes in design can modify how well it grips the surface.
How to properly break in hiking footwear
It’s very important to break the boots in. When they leave the factory, they’re made to default factory specifications and they rarely fit anyone. When you spend some time using them around the house and around the block for about a week, they’re broken in and follow the contours of your feet.
Try to break the shoes in during the morning when your feet aren’t as swollen, and take a break around noon. Repeat for a week. The shoe should feel more comfortable after a week or two.
If your footwear isn’t broken in, you risk having an injury on the trail, or at the very least you’re guaranteed to have a miserable time.
Conclusion
Boots and shoes are extremely important on a hike. The entire trip depends on them working, and they’re the most crucial piece of gear that you can’t really replace or jury rig in the case of a serious tear. Anything duct tape won’t fix is already a cause for alarm and you might have to cut your trip short.
If you footwear can’t handle the conditions of the trail, you run the risk of injuring yourself by falling or slowly wearing out your hips, spine, ankles and knees.
Be very careful when you choose a pair, and be ready to return footwear that doesn’t mesh with your particular needs; if you’re new to the hobby, stay on the safe side and go for day hikes. When you accrue some experience you’ll find out what kind of footwear suits you best.
Do you know someone that might use a few tips and pointers on their next hiking shoe purchase? If you do, please share this article. It might help them out.